What Vero Beach’s taxpayers should know about their water and sewer system 4

COMMENTARY

Editor’s Note:  Much like “Lexington,” an anonymous commentator for The Economist magazine, “Lex et Veritas” will be offering commentary for readers of InsideVero.com.  “Lux et Veritas” addresses local politics, lagoon contamination, quality of education, Libertarian and Liberal excesses, media reporting and agendas, wealth disparity and more.

Lux et Veritas

If one were to abide by comments from the Indian River County officials and a local weekly newspaper, one would assume the Vero Beach water and sewer system is obsolete, provides questionable water quality and services at higher rates than the County.  Such inaccurate observations and opinions are flawed, and represent a flagrant distortion of the facts.

The Vero Beach system is efficient and as a closed operation does not spew any effluents into the environment. In contrast, the County’s water and sewer utility has an experimental process discharging brine into the marshes and waterways.

Vast expanses of the county do not have access to either potable, reuse or waste water from its utility – nor the infrastructure to provide it.  Vero Beach’s service area is either built out or can be increased with minimal additional investment.  For example, to provide septic coverage though the entire system footprint, the estimated expense is in the $800,000 range which would be funded from reserves and over time $500,000 would be recovered from new customer connections.

Rob Bolton, Vero Beach’s water and sewer director is implementing an optimization program, developing a creative and innovative plan to phase out septic fields leaching into the ground. Dr Brian La Pointe, (from Harbor Branch Oceanographic Institute) who undertook major studies of the lagoon believes sewage run off is a significant source of pollution throughout the lagoon.  His detailed July 17 presentation of his findings to the Vero Beach City Council illuminated the perils to the lagoon.

Should future environmental regulations mandate conversion to the municipalities and county systems, the City of Vero Beach is becoming prepared.  Indian River County’s expansion costs are more vulnerable due to the potential significant increase of the sprawling customer base from Sebastian to Oslo and westward versus the limited growth and density of the city.

Total billings of the County are in the $30 million range, Vero Beach in the $17 million range, yet the county, not including the Vero Beach service ara, has over six times the population.  Water and sewer operations contribute more than  $1 million to the City’s General Fund; the County water and sewer operation does not contribute in anyway to the cost of operating County government.  In addition, when its bonds are paid off in less than a decade, Vero Beach can effectively finance the move of its facilities off the Lagoon.

Innovative technology converting sludge (now hauled to a landfill) to fertilizer, replacing more costly water sources, a program which is now in progress, continued productivity improvement and an anticipated 20 percent annual expense reduction of its $2 million electric bill, will further drive down expenses for Vero Beach’s water and sewer operations; additional reuse water will be coming on line increasing revenue, and further improving the system’s profitability to the benefit of the City’s taxpayers.

The age of portions of a the City’s water and sewer distribution network is irrelevant.  Portions of the New York City system are over a century old – critical is the preventive maintenance and continual refurbishment as is Vero Beach’s policy.

Regarding rates, the County and City use different parameters for computation. Indian River County’s are less at lower usage levels, but the County chargers high volume users higher rates than does Vero Beach.  For example, if the City’s approximately 3,000 water and sewer customers on the south barrier island were to begin paying Indian River County rates, the net revenues to the City would increase $200,000 a year.

Creation of an independent regional entity is clearly an option, assuming there is no cross-subsidations to the detriment of any participant.  Such a venture could synchronize rates, establish consistent policies, and develop a holistic plan to manage our environment and implement cost sharing of select operations.

4 comments

  1. In short, the COVB water and sewer systems are a model of efficiency and cost effectiveness relative to comparable systems across Florida. The City market area is dense and compact and 90% plus of infrastructure is in place and in top condition. Its management is lean, sharp and focused and its operations are effective and efficient. They have planned for the future and have already invested in a bullet-proof injection well for untreated or untreatable waste. To fully sewer their entire system would only be a bump in the financial road. They are a great asset to the City and the lagoon and very nicely reduce the city’s tax burden now. Their profitability will only increase with time.

    Contrast the county. They rely on an unapproved brine disposal system that has been in development for several years now, but is still not providing the desired brine dilution. No one talks about what they do with wastewater overflow. They serve only 1/3 iof their market area due to the high cost of infrastructure and their lack of investment for the future. They struggle to break even at rates as high or higher than the COVB, revealing lower efficiency and effectiveness. To fully sewer the more densely populated portions of their system would increase their debt and attendant cost dramatically. We all know what happens when control leaves the local community and moves up the political ladder.

    It seems to me that it would be better for the COVB to take over portions of the county system that are adjacent to the city system and take advantage of the COVB’s technological advantages and efficiencies.

  2. I find the recent report on the City of Vero Beach’s well field featured in 32963, highly disturbing. So disturbing, in fact that I have sent a freedom of information request to the City seeking copies of the recent geosyndel report. DCE and Vinyl Chloride are both listed as Class one carcinogens by the World Health Organization. The City’s wells should not be anywhere close to these contaminants.

Comment - Please use your first and last name. Comments of up to 350 words are welcome.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s